A credit rating is a grade for how likely a debt is to be paid back. Specialised agencies give it, on a scale whose top mark is triple-A. America’s market regulator puts the limit plainly: a credit rating is not a guarantee, and debts rated at the top sometimes go unpaid.
Before 2008 that limit was easy to forget. American mortgages had been cut into slices and sold on, and each slice came with a grade. In 2006 alone, one agency gave triple-A to thirty mortgage investments every working day, and 83% of that year’s triple-A mortgage investments were later downgraded. Between 2000 and 2007 the same agency gave triple-A to almost 45,000 mortgage investments. In early 2010 the number of American companies holding that grade was six.
When the grades stopped being believed, nobody could tell which slices were good and which were not, and banks stopped trusting each other. A grade is only as useful as the care of whoever gives it.